Cultural relativism… revisited yet again

My second last day in Ouagadougou in 2008, I learn from a neighbor that a good Burkinabe friend of mine has been sustaining a big lie for the past two years.

In 2006, he was the best bud to me and the two other Canadians in my project team. On our first night in the village of Sapone, he took us out for a beer. We asked him about himself, and he said he was unmarried and didn’t have any children. Over the course of the summer, we had frequent conversations about gender relations in Burkina Faso, and he impressed us with his desire for equal rights for men and women. He told us that he didn’t want to have a polygamous family, because he wants to love just one wife. (None of us found this guy attractive, but we liked to hang out with him and hear his views.)

Fast forward two years. I’ve kept in touch with the friend since my first summer in Burkina Faso, and we’ve been hanging out again in Ouagadougou. Only this time – without my two friends around – suddenly the guy makes me a bit uncomfortable. My gut tells me something is off, and I suddenly I can’t stand to hang around him. But I figure I owe some sort of loyalty, so I don’t cut off his friendship entirely.

Until I’m talking to my neighbor in Ouagadougou, and she mentions my friend’s wife and children. I figure I must have misheard, so I ask another neighbor and she confirms. Turns out that this dude has been lying to my friends and I about being single for the last two years (with the failed intention, I figure, of getting a little hot nasara action.)

I send him a message telling him I knew about his lie and I’d rather not see him during my last two days in Burkina. (Text messaging is, it seems, the only regular mode of communication in Burkina Faso.) I now had a reason to listen to my unease around him. Case closed.

Except, a few hours later, the dude storms into my little house (in a family courtyard) and starts to yell. Something along the lines of “how dare you call me a liar.” I ask him if he does have a wife and children, which he always said he didn’t. He responds with “Yes I do, but in our culture lying about that kind of thing is not considered wrong. You are being insensitive to my culture.”

(As a side note, another thing he says is “she is not a real wife that I chose – she is just a wife that my father bought for me.”)

Anyways, anyone who knows me knows that the topic of cultural relativism is something that fascinates me, partially because I am so often torn over the subject. After my friend finally leaves in a huff, I start to worry. I hate the idea that I am rejecting my friend due to differences in culture. Am I really being insensitive?

Later that evening, I’m out with a good Burkinabe friend who lives next door. A young woman about my age, this friend has always been there to help me out since I moved into the neighborhood. I decide to seek her advice and tell her about the whole argument.

She listens quietly until I mention the part about lying and culture. She suddenly looks angry. “That isn’t true,” she says. “Lying is not a part of my culture and it is offensive for him to say that. I would never lie to you, just as I would expect you never to lie to me.” I realize that what my friend did was, in fact, creepy and wrong. I should not only trust my gut feelings, but hold him to the same standards that I would any friend. Despite the supposed political incorrectness of using any sorts of universal norms, I stand by this decision. It seems much more wrong and patronizing to use culture to excuse absolutely everything.

(This image is unrelated… except it’s from last summer in Burkina.)

Comments 1

  1. Wade | Vagabondjourney.com wrote:

    I agree with you completely on your conclusion. The idea of cultural relativism is often used as a crutch for individuals to go against the bounds of their own culture when in the presence of foreigners. Foreigners are oftentimes “wild cards” when interacting with local people because it is assumed that we do not know the local customs and/or will not hold people to following their own cultural rules. This often works out really well, as I have had many people really open up to me in China/ Japan in ways that they could not if there were other Chinese/ Japanese people around. But, in your case, this situation can also go the other way. This fellow seemed to have been trying to use the fact that you are an outsider and do not fully know the inter workings of his social structure as a crow bar to get something from you. The “you don’t understand us” cop-out is a pretty common defensive blanket when you finally realize what is going on.

    It is my impression that you did, in fact, FULLY understood what was going on. From where I am sitting, it seems as if your analysis was probably pretty right on.

    I think it is great that you called this fellow out and confronted him when you could have just walked away silently.

    If nothing else, it makes for good reading.

    Thanks,

    Wade

    Posted 06 May 2009 at 5:59 am

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *